Washington Examiner columnist Joe Concha went on Fox News recently and said what anybody who lives within fifty miles of the Rio Grande already knows: rushing the border in a caravan right now is a fool's errand. He called it that, word for word, and I appreciate a commentator who doesn't dance around it. You can watch the clip here.

Concha's argument, as far as the clip goes, is that the caravans are charging at a border that's being secured, and that the effort to secure it is necessary. That's the verified part, and it's enough. Everything else I'm about to say is mine, from where I sit.

What I know comes from my own fence line. Enforcement actually works now. Agents can do their jobs. Crossings on this stretch have fallen so far that some weeks you'd hardly know there's a corridor behind my pasture, and I say that as a man who spent two decades knowing exactly where it ran. Concha didn't have to say any of that for it to be true. I've got the repaired gates to prove it.

I've watched this movie before, and I'll own that this is my recollection, not a filing cabinet. Over the years I've seen the pattern enough times to be tired of it: the caravan moves, the cameras move with it, the NGOs show up with their clipboards, and a fair share of the group ends up in stash houses right here in Kinney County while the smugglers collect the balance. The organizers never ride in the caravan themselves. Funny how that works. In my experience, they take their cut up front and hand the risky work to whoever's cheapest and most expendable, sometimes kids barely old enough to shave. When one driver gets caught, there's another one lined up behind him.

What Concha got right that most studio people miss is that this thing isn't a humanitarian movement. It's a business, and the cartels run it like one. Most everybody walking north in one of those groups owes somebody money for the trip, and that somebody isn't walking anywhere. A caravan is a product launch with feet. The people selling it are taking cash from desperate folks to sell a door that's closing, and closing hard.

The hard part is that the people walking north genuinely believe the door is still open. They were told that by the same people charging them thousands of dollars a head. When they get to the line and find sensors, cameras, wall, and Border Patrol agents who are actually allowed to do their jobs, the smuggler is already back across the river recruiting the next group. The migrant eats the disappointment. The cartel eats the profit.

I'll say it plain because I've cleaned up after the alternative for thirty years: the border being closed is the most humane thing that ever happened to this stretch of country. Fewer bodies in the brush. Fewer kids stacked in trailers. Fewer water lines cut on my neighbors' places. Concha called the caravans a fool's errand on national television, and there wasn't a word of it I'd take back for him.