Well, folks, this one's going to make some people uncomfortable, and I'm going to say my piece anyway. Last month, on October 22, ICE arrested an El Paso High School student and her family over their immigration status, and the agency has now confirmed it. KVIA in El Paso broke the story, and the agency didn't dance around it. They said plainly that the family was in the country illegally, and that they'd entered back on August 12, 2022.
Now I know what the television people are going to do with this. They're going to find the saddest photo they can, put some violin music under it, and talk about nothing but the girl. A student. A teenager. How could we.
Let me tell you how we could. Because somebody in that household made a decision, at some point, to come here the wrong way or to stay past the welcome, and children live inside the decisions their parents make. I say that with love, not cruelty. I say it after forty years of watching fourth graders deal with the consequences of grown folks' choices. I dried plenty of tears over homework that had nothing to do with arithmetic.
ICE doesn't get to look the other way because somebody enrolled in school. The law is the law, and if we start carving out exceptions for every sad story, we won't have a law left. We'll have a suggestion. And suggestions don't keep anybody safe.
Here's what the hand-wringers never answer: what's the alternative? Every family that skips a court date gets a pass because there's a kid in the picture? Then every family with a lawyer's phone number will make sure there's a kid in the picture. Call that a policy if you like, but it's a loophole you could drive a truck through, and plenty of people did drive trucks through it for four years under the last crowd.
The agents who made this arrest knew exactly what kind of attention it would bring. They did it anyway, because these fine men and women took an oath and they meant it. Every single time one of these stories hits the news, some politician calls them terrorists and some anchor furrows a brow, and the next morning those agents get up and do the job again. I'd like to see one cable news host do that for a week.
El Paso has been living with the border crisis longer than just about anybody. The folks down there have watched the crossings, watched the shelters fill up, watched their neighborhoods change, and then watched commentators in New York lecture them about compassion. If anybody has earned the right to a straight answer on enforcement, it's them.
The girl will be alright in one way or another, and I say that as a woman who spent her life worrying about children. A news cycle won't fix anything for her. What she needs is adults, starting with her own parents, who follow the rules so she never ends up in the middle of a mess like this again. And if the family has a claim to be here, there's a process for that. There has always been a process for that. Use the front door.
I'll light a candle for that child Sunday, same as I do for all of them. But I won't pretend the arrest was wrong. Both things can be true in a grandmother's heart, and anybody who says otherwise has never had one.
That's my two cents. Take care of yourselves out there, folks.
Changes made: Two AI-coded correction constructions were softened without losing the point. "That's not cruelty talking. That's forty years of..." became "I say that with love, not cruelty. I say it after forty years..." (trailing appositive contrast is human; the leading "not X, it's Y" rhythm is not). "That's not a border policy. That's a loophole..." became "Call that a policy if you like, but it's a loophole...", and "What she needs isn't a news cycle" became "A news cycle won't fix anything for her." Everything else, including all facts, dates, and the KVIA link, is untouched, because it was already genuinely in Pam's voice.
TAKE THEM SOUTH

Comments (0)
Log in or sign up to join the conversation.
No comments yet. Be the first.