Well, mark the calendar. Saturday Night Live opened a recent show with a sketch about a tech CEO caught in a messy personal scandal, played for laughs, with no sermon attached, and the audience that has spent years trashing the show actually tipped its hat. You can read the details over at the Daily Mail, but the short version is that the cold open took on Jensen Huang of Nvidia and reports of an affair, and viewers who normally wouldn't cross the street to watch the show said, out loud and in public, that it was funny.
I don't get to say this often, so let me enjoy it: they were right on both counts. The sketch was funny, and the praise was earned. The writers found a story with an actual comic engine in it, a silicon titan with more money than sense caught doing something foolish, and they rode it. No character stopped mid-scene to educate us. Nobody delivered a monologue about how we ought to feel. A man made a fool of himself, the cast made it worse for him, and the audience laughed. That used to be the whole job, back when the show had teeth and Chevy Chase was falling down desks for the sheer joy of it.
I've watched this show since the Belushi years, and I've watched it slowly turn into a church newsletter with a band. For a long stretch there, to my eyes, the cold open was a press release with punchlines nobody laughed at. The studio audience applauded positions instead of laughing at jokes, and that is the death rattle of any comedy institution. When your crowd is clapping in agreement rather than laughing, you're doing a town hall, sweetheart, not satire.
So when the writers room finally stages an intervention on itself, when it picks a target because the target is ridiculous rather than because the target is safe and approved, I'm going to say so. Good sketch. More of these. The fact that it surprised anybody tells you how low the bar had sunk. A comedy show doing comedy should feel like Tuesday, not like a miracle.
Now for the rain on the parade, because you knew it was coming. One good cold open is a stay of execution, not a pardon. Hollywood has learned this dance before: offend nobody, lose everybody, panic, course-correct for six weeks, then wander right back into the lecture hall once the executives stop sweating. SNL has more than fifty years of muscle memory, and only some of that muscle memory is comic. The test isn't whether they can do one sketch about a tech billionaire's private life. The test is whether they can do it again next week, and the week after, when the target is somebody their own writers went to brunch with.
Satire that only bites when it's convenient is a party trick, and a cheap one. The original show, the one that premiered in 1975, went after everybody because everybody was fair game and nobody in the building thought they were the moral authority of the Western Hemisphere. If this version of the show wants that reputation back, it has to keep the blade out even when it cuts a friend.
I'll be watching next Saturday like I always do, remote in one hand and my skepticism in the other. The Rex Theater taught me a long time ago that one good reel doesn't redeem a bad picture. But it's a start, and I'm lady enough to say so.
TAKE THEM SOUTH

Comments (0)
Log in or sign up to join the conversation.
No comments yet. Be the first.