ICE is no longer immediately rearresting detainees in Colorado after a judge frees them on a court order. The change follows pressure from a federal judge who wanted answers on whether agents were re-detaining people minutes after judges ordered their release. The court was not going to tolerate that practice, and anyone paying attention could see it.
The Christian Science Monitor reported on the shift this week. Short version: detainees in the district of Colorado who win release orders from immigration judges will no longer be grabbed at the door and put back in a cell while the government files an appeal.
The reporting on this has been muddy, so here are the mechanics. When an immigration judge orders someone released on bond, the government can appeal. That appeal used to come with an immediate rearrest, sometimes the same day, sometimes within hours. The detainee would win in the morning and be back in a cell by dinner. The courtroom victory was real on paper and worthless in practice.
Now, in Colorado at least, that's done. The rearrest-on-the-spot tactic is off the table while the appeal plays out.
In my judgment this was a bad tactic, and it was going to get burned down eventually. My years in federal law enforcement taught me one lesson that applies here: you don't win by making judges feel like their orders are decorative. Federal judges have long memories, long dockets, and contempt powers. Every rearrest at the courthouse door invites a judge somewhere to take it personally, and judges who take things personally write injunctions. Broad ones. Ones that don't just cover Colorado. That's my read, and time tends to back it up.
That's the cost of tactics that look aggressive on a spreadsheet and reckless in a courtroom. The mission didn't need this fight. ICE is running serious enforcement right now. You don't need to snatch somebody off the courthouse steps the same day a judge lets him go to keep that pace. File the appeal, do it by the book, and if the ruling stands, the guy walks until his case resolves. That's how the system was built to run.
The judge pressed the government over whether agents were re-detaining people minutes after release, and the policy is gone now. That sequence tells you what you need to know. When a federal judge starts asking pointed questions about what your agents did last week, the argument is already going badly. That's as far as the reporting goes, and it's far enough.
The open-borders crowd will crow about this like it's the fall of Rome. One tactic retired in one judicial district after a judge said stop. Enforcement in Colorado continues. Appeals continue. Removal flights continue. The count keeps rolling.
But there's a lesson here worth saying out loud. Enforcement works when it's surgical and documented. The moment it looks like it's dodging the referee, judges step in, and they don't step in small. Better to lose one rearrest than hand a district court the excuse to write the next nationwide injunction.
Scoreboard: one tactic retired in Colorado. Everything else still running.
TAKE THEM SOUTH

Comments (0)
Log in or sign up to join the conversation.
No comments yet. Be the first.