Well, we're doing this again. The latest chatter, making the rounds after GCN reported on the speculation, has Hunter Schafer's name attached to the Bond girl conversation, opposite a Robert Pattinson 007 that is itself, to be clear, pure rumor at this stage. Nothing is cast, nothing is confirmed, and yet here we all are, talking about a movie nobody has agreed to make. Somebody clearly thinks this is a well that hasn't been drawn from enough.

The comparison being floated is to Caroline Cossey, who appeared in 1981's For Your Eyes Only, a small part in the crowd of a Bond picture, before the press outed her and, as The Guardian put it in her own telling, made it a nightmare. Cossey was a working actress who wanted what every actress wants, a part and a paycheck. What's being discussed now is something else entirely, and I'll call it what it is: a press release wearing a screenplay.

My objection is simple. Bond is a specific thing. He's a cad, a killer, and a walking tailored suit with a drinking problem, and the women in those movies historically fell into two camps, the ones who could hold the screen with him and the ones who existed to be rescued. The franchise has spent sixty years earning a particular kind of pleasure, the kind my generation paid a dollar-fifty to enjoy at the Rex with our shoes sticking to the floor. When a studio decides the next entry exists primarily to make a statement, my experience says the statement is all you get. The Marvels and Lightyear come to mind, and I've written about one of them at length already.

Now, the caveat, because I'm fair even when the trades aren't. Hunter Schafer can act; anyone who saw Euphoria knows that. And a trans actress playing a glamorous, dangerous woman in a Bond film could work beautifully in the hands of people whose first loyalty is to the story. In my reading of the situation, Barbara Broccoli's people lost the keys to the kingdom and the new management has shown no evidence it cares about anything older than last quarter's press clippings. That's my characterization, and I'll stand on it. But a rumor like this from this crowd reads as positioning, not casting.

That's what grinds me about the whole exercise. If Schafer is the best actor for the part, cast her, shoot it, and let the movie argue for itself, the way every great piece of casting in history was done. Nobody issued a press release about Sean Connery. The studio just put him on screen and let him work. Instead we get trial balloons, fury online, counter-fury, and a movie nobody has made yet already carrying forty pounds of baggage it didn't earn. The audience gets lectured, the discourse gets fed, and the film, if it ever arrives, gets graded on politics instead of whether it's any good.

I'll say what I always say. Make a good movie and I'll be in the third row with my popcorn. Make a statement and I'll be home with TCM and Honor Blackman, who never needed a think piece to prove she belonged in the picture.