The strangest act in Hollywood right now is the Harry Potter press tour, and Paapa Essiedu has learned its trickiest step. Per Fandom Pulse, the man playing Severus Snape in HBO's new series has spent the opening weeks of the promotional run talking about his character and the show, and then, when a reporter asked about J.K. Rowling, he declined to comment. There was no careful hedging, no diplomatic runaround. Just a polite slammed door.

Think about what that silence costs. The woman wrote the books. She built the castle. Her name is on every poster, every trailer, and every licensing agreement funding the whole enterprise. An actor can spend an hour on the craft of playing Snape and then go quiet the second the author comes up, and we're all supposed to pretend that's a normal way to promote a television show. Most of us were raised with a simpler rule: if you can't say something nice, say nothing at all. He's following it to the letter, and it echoes louder than anything he said all afternoon.

I don't need an actor's politics. I need an actor. In my day, the people on the screen sold the picture and that was the end of it, and I don't recall any of them pausing mid-junket to lecture anybody. But HBO has reportedly built this series on one of the most popular book franchises ever published while, as far as I can tell, hoping nobody remembers the author exists, and the cast has been left to perform that tap dance one junket at a time. It's like mounting a revival of My Fair Lady while asking the press to kindly avoid mentioning Lerner and Loewe.

The cowardice here flows uphill. Essiedu didn't build this trap; the studio did, or at least that's how it looks from the cheap seats. HBO wants Rowling's world, Rowling's characters, and, one imagines, Rowling's considerable revenue, without Rowling's name spoken above a whisper. So an actor gets sent out to promote a show whose creator can't be discussed, and when the question lands, he eats the awkward moment while the executives stay home. The suits will collect their bonuses either way. The Snape actor takes the hard questions.

Say what you will about Alan Rickman, and I've said plenty over the years, all of it fond. When that man sat down for an interview, he talked about the work. I'd like to think he'd have had little patience for a publicist's list of approved topics. We could use a little more of that again, and a little less of this choreographed silence.