Dave Chappelle is in hot water again, and this time even some of his longtime defenders are keeping their distance. During a recent set, Chappelle made a crude remark about the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk, and the internet did what the internet does. The backlash was immediate and loud, with plenty of commenters calling the joke, in the delicate phrasing of the day, "disgusting." You can read the rundown over at MSN.

I've watched Chappelle work since half the people posting outrage clips were in diapers, and I'll say plainly what I always say: a joke about a murdered man is a hard thing to land, and from the reporting, this one didn't land. It crashed in a fire visible from space. Richard Pryor could work a tragedy because he earned it, night after night, decade after decade, building a bridge with the audience before he walked them across it. If your whole setup is shock, you've confused gasping with laughing, and gasping doesn't sell tickets twice.

Now for the part that will annoy everybody, because somebody has to say it. The same entertainment industry that spent years handing Chappelle trophies for "brave" comedy is now acting as though he violated some sacred covenant. He didn't fall from grace; he wandered off the reservation of approved targets. When the joke was aimed at people the studios don't like, he was a genius. The moment the aim drifted, he became a problem. The moral outrage here is awfully selective, and we're allowed to notice that while still saying the joke was lousy. Both things can be true in the same paragraph, I promise.

What I keep coming back to is how little anybody seems to actually believe in anymore. Either comedy gets to go to dark places and live with the results, applause and fury alike, or it doesn't. You don't get to cheer the dark places you enjoy and cancel the ones you don't, and Chappelle of all people should know by now that the rules change the second you cross the wrong crowd. He built a career betting that the audience could handle him. This time, I think he bet wrong, and the audience is telling him so at full volume, which is also part of the deal.

My mother used to say you can tell a joke about anything, but you'd better bring the joke. If all you brought was the anything, don't be surprised when the room goes quiet. Chappelle will survive this; he's survived worse from better critics. But the next special will tell us whether he heard the silence or decided it was applause from people afraid to boo.