Every Simpsons fan of a certain vintage knows about "Stark Raving Dad." Michael Jackson voiced a 300-pound mental patient named Leon Kompowsky who believed he was Michael Jackson. It was a sensation when it aired in 1990, and then, once the allegations against Jackson became more than the studio wanted to carry, the episode was pulled from circulation. Gone, the way a studio disposes of a thing once it decides the thing costs more than it's worth.
Except the character apparently refused to stay buried. As Collider reports, this year's Treehouse of Horror brought the familiar face from that pulled episode back to Springfield, 35 years after his debut, and it came on the heels of Apu's own return to the show after years on the sidelines. Two rehabilitations in one season, from a series that spent the last decade apologizing for its own catalog. Somebody over there has changed direction, and quietly.
Now, I have watched The Simpsons since Bart was on t-shirts and getting principals' panties in a bunch, and I'll tell you what interests me here. It's the quietness of it. No press release, no victory lap, no think piece about "reclaiming the legacy." They just slid the man back into an episode, the way you'd let an old friend in through the kitchen door so nobody at the party makes a fuss. For a company that normally trumpets its own courage from the rooftops, silence is the tell. Courage they can market. Discretion they actually have to practice.
Some context for the younger readers. "Stark Raving Dad" was a crown jewel of the third season, back when the show could still surprise you. Jackson was a fan of the show, the part was written for him, and he took a pseudonym credit, John Jay Smith, so his involvement stayed under wraps. The "Lisa, It's Your Birthday" sequence alone earned the episode a permanent spot in the pantheon. Then the show pulled it, and that was the era of the great scrubbing, when every archive in town got a moral audit, and frankly some of it was overdue and some of it was panic. You can decide for yourself which category this one fell into. I know which one I'd file it under, and I've been filing things since before the video store had a Simpsons section.
What makes the return clever rather than craven is the venue. Treehouse of Horror exists outside continuity, outside consequence, outside the rules. It's the show's carnival tent, where anything can appear because nothing counts. If the character had come back in a regular episode, the lawyers would still be vibrating. In a Halloween anthology, he's a ghost, and ghosts don't need clearance. Whoever set this up understood the one loophole the compliance department forgot to weld shut, and I salute them.
The timing with Apu matters, too. Apu spent years treated like a scandal the show had to atone for, and bringing him back with a new voice was its own kind of slow walk back from the ledge. Reviving Leon Kompowsky on top of that reads less like an endorsement of anything than like the writers reclaiming pieces of their own history from the people who took them away. The episodes were theirs. The characters were theirs. Someone apparently remembered that.
I don't know if this opens the door to "Stark Raving Dad" returning to streaming in full, and I won't pretend to. Studios un-ban things about as often as they refund ticket money. But a character walking back through a door that was bricked over for years is worth noticing, because it suggests somebody finally did the math and realized the audience never asked for the wall in the first place. We liked the episode. We still like the episode. That used to count for something in show business.
So here's to Leon Kompowsky, back in Springfield after 35 years in the wilderness. The Rex Theater taught me that the audience has a longer memory than the front office ever does. Every so often, painfully slowly, the front office catches up.
TAKE THEM SOUTH

Comments (4)
Log in or sign up to join the conversation.